Skip to content
Sign In Subscribe
• | 

Sheffield gets serious about heritage

Tribune Sun
Kelham Island is one of Sheffield's most historic areas. Photo: Mick Knapton/Wikimedia Commons.

Plus, a fell running war breaks out on the moors

Dear readers — From our indispensable role in the industrial revolution, to our magnificent buildings, to football, to Henderson’s relish… the list goes on. Sheffield is oozing with history, and many of us are incredibly proud of it. However, for quite a few years, some critics have argued that our council doesn't seem to care enough 

All that could be about to change, as the council develops the Sheffield Heritage Matrix, a comprehensive list of all the city's historic assets. The move has received a cautious welcome from campaigners, but will it be enough? That's today’s big story.

As well as that, fleet-footed antagonism on the hills above Sheffield, a quiz about the Beatles, and a lovely home in Broomhill.

Stuck for a present? This Christmas, give the gift of good journalism to your nearest and dearest with a specially discounted subscription to The Tribune. Choose from either three months (£15), six months (£30) or a full year (£49.99), add a personal message, and schedule it to arrive on Christmas morning (or whenever suits you). We’ll take care of the rest!

As well as being a very thoughtful present, a gift sub has the advantages of needing no wrapping or queueing, and you’ll be supporting local journalism while you’re at it. And, if you’ve got loved ones in another city, we have sister papers doing the same kind of quality local journalism across the UK!


In case you missed it ⏪

For our weekend read, we waded back into the unholy mess that is Sheffield politics at the moment, after news broke that Labour and the Greens — who have jointly run the council since May — have finally broken up. The marital strife between the two parties was triggered by a motion passed at the national Green party conference declaring that Zionism is racist but, at least for a few days, it looked as if our local politicians would be able to work things out. 

According to deputy Green leader Alexi Dimond, a deal was reached just before the full council meeting on 4 November, until Labour leader Fran Belbin knocked on his office door to tell him there had been a last-minute hold up. His party was later presented with a new draft of the joint statement they’d agree to release, which he claims “contained much more apologetic language” and specifically disavowed the national party’s motion. 

Lots of readers wanted to carry on the debate in the comments: you can join in here.

Original illustration for The Tribune by Jake Greenhalgh.

On Wednesday, we revisited some of our most popular recent stories, as part of our semi-regular “Where are they now?” series. This latest edition provided updates on the city’s most hotly-contested grass verge, the Peak District tunnel and the pro-Palestine activists accused of “jew-hunting” in Woodseats earlier this year. “Brilliant idea following up on these,” said member Joe Ware. “It really adds value to the reporting.”

And on Thursday, Mollie visited Wybourn Islamic Centre to discuss how they’re coping after two shocking hate crimes in recent months. In September and again in October, desecrated Qur'ans have been left outside their door, although the mosque’s worshippers remain remarkably dignified in the face of such provocation. 


The big picture: That’s a wrap 🎁

Leah’s Yard all done up for Christmas. Photo: James O’Hara.

Perhaps it’s cheeky to shine a spotlight on our own offices but we think they’re just too beautiful not to share. Christmas at Leah’s Yard started on Friday and the entire building has been wrapped up like a gift to the city, thanks to the talented Laura Hopkins from Elegant Design Events. Also open now at Leah’s Yard is Easy Peeler (pictured bottom left), which claims to be Sheffield’s smallest department store.


The big story: Sheffield gets serious about heritage

Top line: In the spirit of the holiday season, Sheffield council is making a list and they’re checking it twice — a list of the city’s heritage assets, that is. The Sheffield Heritage Matrix will include our most notable assets, including archaeological sites, regeneration projects and historic buildings in danger of falling apart. Our city’s leaders have long been accused (by some) of not valuing our heritage enough. Will this matrix be enough to change that?

A chequered past: For a city whose cup runneth over when it comes to history, Sheffield’s record at preserving it leaves something to be desired. Many notable buildings have been knocked down over the years, while others (such as the Old Town Hall on Waingate) are falling into disrepair.

  • Take the abrupt demolition of the Market Tavern on Exchange Street, which some would consider a particularly egregious example of the council’s lax attitude. After the building was demolished in 2024, council officers initially claimed their hand was forced by the spontaneous collapse of part of the building — until local outlet Now Then proved this was not true. 
  • On the other hand, you couldn’t accuse the local authority of not caring about the city’s heritage at all. The Heart of the City scheme has preserved key buildings like our office Leah’s Yard (pictured above) and the council recently purchased the gorgeous Salvation Army Citadel building from an owner who has left it empty and degrading for many years. 

Clearer priorities: According to a recent report, Sheffield council has identified where it has been going wrong. Information about heritage assets has not been readily available and the responsibility to care for them has been spread too thin. As far as we can tell, our heritage has suffered from something like the bystander effect: it has been everyone’s job to look after it, so everyone has assumed someone else will. The report argues the answer to this inefficiency and confusion is the Sheffield Heritage Matrix, since “endorsing a coordinated programme will help deliver clearer priorities”.

Kelham Island is one of Sheffield's most historic areas. Photo: Mick Knapton/Wikimedia Commons.

What should be included? Of course, deciding how high priority each heritage asset should be is an inherently subjective call. Some assets, such as iconic buildings like Park Hill, are an obvious choice — beyond that, it can prove more tricky. For example, our long history of producing steel and cutlery is an important part of the city’s history, but have we been banging that drum a bit too much? At a recent council meeting to discuss this topic, Green Councillor Paul Turpin questioned whether the city has “relied on knives and forks for too long”.

  • For years, many local people have argued Sheffield doesn’t make enough of our role in the birth of football. Was it a grave mistake, back in 2011, for Sheffield FC to flog off the first written rules of football for £900,000? Could our “virtual museum” — Sheffield Home of Football — one day have a physical presence?
  • Laura Alston, the council’s heritage development manager, argues we shouldn’t forget to celebrate our so-called “intangible heritage,” such as food and music. Should a list that mostly consists of buildings also make room for traditional carol singing or even Sheffield fishcakes?

Refreshing development: The city’s heritage advocates have so far given the council’s plans a cautious welcome. Robin Hughes, from Hallamshire Historic Buildings, said he expects the matrix to be “dynamic and evolving” and not just a one-time snapshot, but feels it’s a move in the right direction. “Given that, a few years ago, the Council seemed to have limited awareness of the heritage value even of the buildings and places for which it has responsibility, this feels like a refreshing new development.”

Our take: Sheffield council is eager to boost tourism to our city, so celebrating the history that is uniquely ours seems like an obvious selling point. We’re actually surprised a list like this hasn’t existed before. However, laying out what we have is really just the first step — the real test will be whether this matrix manages to focus minds, as the council hopes. It won’t be easy to balance preserving our history alongside all the other priorities the council has to manage and there may still be tough decisions in the years to come.

What would you place at the top of our heritage matrix? Let us know in the comments below.


Your Tribune briefing 🗞️

🚽 We loved this piece in last Friday’s edition of The Times, for which a reporter spent 24 hours at the “earthly paradise” of Welcome Break Rotherham, to celebrate it being named the best service station in Britain. “They say the thing that stands out is the toilets,” one employee told him. “You can’t believe how good they are.” 

🚧 Investigating and repairing the mineshaft discovered beneath the tram tracks at Birley Lane could cost as much as £1.5 million. Since the shaft was discovered last month, blue line trams haven’t been able to go past Gleadless Townend but, in an interview with The Star last week, South Yorkshire Mayor Oliver Coppard admitted the problem was unlikely to be fixed “this side of Christmas”. Prof Liz Laycock from Sheffield Hallam University told the BBC that there are tens of thousands of unmapped mine shafts all over the country, meaning it’s entirely feasible that engineers did not know about the mine shaft when Supertram was constructed 30 years ago.

One of the trig points that has been painted in the colours of the Dark Peak Fell Runners. Photo: Debbie Williamson.

🎽 Fell running teams aren’t normally known for beefing with other squads, but that is exactly what seems to be happening on the hills above Sheffield. We were informed of the bizarre development by our regular contributor David Bocking, who told us that competition between different groups of runners seems to have exploded in an unusual way. “Horror in local fell running and trig point communities with several local landmarks daubed in Dark Peak Fell Runners colours,” he said. “Dark Peak deny responsibility and have set out to the hills with paintbrushes and restorative white paint.” Why this is happening is unclear. If you know more about why trig points are being defaced, get in touch.


Home of the week 🏡

This beautifully presented three bedroom end terrace in Broomhill is nestled at the top of a private drive in one of Sheffield’s most sought-after suburbs. It’s on the market for £230,000.


Things to do 📅

Quiz 🎸 Long-term readers will know we’re big fans of the Sheffield Beatles Project, the group of Sheffield musicians who come together every Christmas to perform Beatles albums in full. Well, this Christmas, they’re hosting a special Beatles Quiz, with prizes and opportunities to meet the band at Crookes Social Club on Monday evening. Dan will be attending and is determined to win, so come prepared!

Craft 🧵 Readers will remember our piece from earlier this year about Ed’s Workshop, the little mesters workshop for young people with additional needs. This Christmas, for the very first time, they are opening their doors to the public. On Tuesdays (12-2) and Saturdays (10-3) in November and December, you can browse a unique collection of handmade wood, pewter, and silver items — handcrafted in Sheffield using reclaimed materials.

Music 🎹 On Thursday, get in the mood for Jools’ Annual Hootenanny as the man himself returns to Sheffield City Hall with his famous Rhythm & Blues Orchestra. Renowned for his exuberant live shows, Jools will once again be backed by the full power and finesse of his superb musicians, delivering an evening of blues music, swing music, boogie woogie and ska, packed with musical virtuosity and joyful spontaneity. Tickets are priced from £45.75.

If someone forwarded you this newsletter, click here to sign up to get quality local journalism in your inbox.


Comments

Latest