Tax evasion, bribery and the mother of all family feuds

Dear members — what do the John O'Gaunt pub in Gleadless, the Hurlfield View Care Home, and roughly 500 derelict garages have in common?

All have been demolished, or are set to be demolished; and in every case the contractor who got the job is MHH Contracting Limited, paid for by Sheffield council. In recent years, the company has carried out hundreds of thousands of pounds worth of activity for the council.

If MHH rings bells, it might be because they came up in our recent piece about the Hague family, some of Sheffield’s wealthiest landowners. MHH is owned by Martin Hague, who came out on top when the family had an almighty falling out in 2009. 

Given the Hagues’ significant landholdings, and MHH's status as a major council contractor, we decided to keep looking into it. We still had lots of questions: what, exactly, caused the initial rift? When Martin Hague mentioned “lying and deceit”, what was he actually talking about?

Since then, there have been two major developments. The first is that we’ve uncovered the judgement from the original court case that began it all. It’s a truly extraordinary document, laying bare just what went so wrong. As the two sides of the family tried to damage the other in the judge’s eyes, details of major tax evasion, bribes, and a secretive multimillion pound hotel deal all spilled out (plus an extraordinary allegation that a dead cow was mutilated by blow torch to get insurance money.)

The second development is that, for the first time, a member of this highly secretive family has spoken to the press about just what has gone on in the Hague empire. “There’s been a lot of mud-slinging,” they told us.

Your Tribune briefing 🗞️

🏫 Sheffield Hallam University is to make £27 million of further cuts over the coming year, The Tribune has learned. The cuts reportedly include £16 million from further staff cuts (in addition to the 1,000 staff members that have been cut in the last two years), and £11 million from taking staff out of the Teachers’ Pension Scheme and employing staff through a wholly owned subsidiary instead. If you know more about this story, get in touch.

⛳ Over the weekend, we published a story about the “Loxley alp” — a name given to the 136,000 tonnes of waste piled on a driving range in one of Sheffield’s most beautiful valleys. The owners claim the inert waste will be used to remodel the land into a stunning golf facility — but many locals have had their doubts and believe it is essentially being used as a landfill site. Three days later, Loxley Driving Range and Country Club announced that “after much thought and careful planning”, they had decided to temporarily close the range while they work to “refine our layout” and introduce new amenities. “This is not a goodbye – it’s a new beginning,” they wrote. That same day, our reporter Dan Hayes also saw diggers at the site attempting to reduce the size of the waste mountain. If you know more, get in touch.

🎸 The Leadmill has launched a crowdfunding campaign to secure a new permanent venue in Sheffield. The campaign, which has the snappy title #TheNewLeadmill — Powered By The People, wants to raise £30,000 to help with funds for a deposit, fit-out costs and the long-term lease of a new venue. A new music venue in Sheffield would of course be a great thing and we wish them well. However, given the fact that Leadmill Holdings Ltd reported assets of £4.3 million in March 2024, you would imagine owner Phil Mills might be able to find £30,000. The crowdfunder currently stands at £5,700 and you can contribute here.

🎤 Where might you find disgraced London solicitor and freehold owner Andrew Milne and disgraced former royal Andrew Mountbatten Windsor in the same place? Probably nowhere to be honest, with the exception of Private Eye’s Page 94 Podcast. Their latest episode, “A tale of two Andrews”, explores in depth Milne’s recent stalking conviction, the Solicitors Regulation Authority’s decision to bar him from practising, and his aggressive letters to Sheffield leaseholders, before going on to discuss the first arrest of a senior royal in over 350 years. You can take a look here.

🗳️ Local election campaigning has begun. On Saturday, Reform campaigner Matt Smith spent the day posting leaflets through letterboxes of residents in Sheffield West, saying on X that “the response has been incredible!”. However, at least one resident wasn’t best pleased, as shown by a video captured by her Ring doorbell of her handing the leaflet back pointing out his southern accent and saying “We don’t want you racist pricks”. Have you received any campaign leaflets — Reform, Green, Labour, Lib Dem or otherwise — through the letterbox yet? Send a photo to Mollie.

Tax evasion, bribery and the mother of all family feuds

By Dan Hayes

The meeting took place on 21 September 2005. It was attended by the three Hague children: Martin, David and Dianne, plus their mother Jean, Martin’s wife Jean Angela, David’s wife Rosemary and Mr Midgley, the family’s long-time accountant. 

It was an annual fixture to discuss pensions — usually a pretty boring affair. But trouble had been brewing among the Hague clan.

The previous year, Martin — the youngest of the Hague siblings — had made a huge purchase, laying down a cool £6.65 million (plus VAT) to buy the Hallam Tower Hotel. The hotel in its heyday had hosted stars like David Bowie and Elton John, but by the mid-2000s it was tired and shabby.

Martin had found the millions to buy the hotel from family funds. There was just one problem. He hadn’t told them.