Skip to content
Sign In Subscribe
• | 

In defence of the Egg Box

Tribune Sun
The Egg Box from Arundel Gate in an undated photo. Photo: Public domain.

‘One day anarchy broke out. Someone opened all the windows’

Stand in the middle of St Paul’s Square today, surrounded by modern office blocks and mid-price restaurants, and you might just detect a ripple in the quotidian fabric of the city’s daily life. The lingering remnant of a long-lost local oddity. For what is now paving slabs beneath your feet was once the site of Sheffield’s strangest building. Four stories high and covered in a repeating pattern of curious geometric shapes, the pale yellow structure stretched from Tudor Square to Charles Street, looming over the Peace Gardens like an alien spacecraft.

I am, of course, talking about the Egg Box or, to give it its official title, the Town Hall Extension. Built in 1977 to meet Sheffield council’s need for more office space, the building was meant to last for the next 500 years. In the end, it didn’t even reach 25. Perhaps seeing it destroyed in 1984’s harrowing nuclear war movie Threads planted the germ of an idea in someone’s head because, just 18 years later, the Egg Box was levelled in real life too — not by a nuclear warhead, but by the council itself.

They say true genius is never appreciated in its own time and, by that metric, the Egg Box must have had genius to spare. It has now been gone for almost as long as it once stood and, to this day, the vast majority of locals mutually agree that it was oppressive, ugly and curiously dirty-looking. “Best part of Threads was this thing getting blown to smithereens,” reads one typical comment online. Another local recalls getting married there, before adding: “The place is cursed.” Despite how many staff would have once roamed its halls, my efforts to find people with memories of the Egg Box they’re willing to share proves an uphill battle, almost as if most people want to erase it from record.

So, how did a building that started with such high hopes end up being torn down in ignominy less than a quarter of a century later? The conventional wisdom is that it was a grand folly; a tangible example of the way some modernist architects got ahead of themselves with crazier and crazier designs; what Jeff Goldblum's character in Jurassic Park calls thinking too much about what you can do and not enough about what you should do. But is that true?

Sheffield deserves great journalism. You can help make it happen.

You're halfway there, the rest of the story is behind this paywall. Join the Tribune for full access to local news that matters, just £8.95/month.

Subscribe

Already have an account? Sign In


Latest